x
schencka
Comment on inside higher ed
Thanks for the link to the Washington Monthly piece, but I wish I had a dollar for every gee-whiz article on "disruption" and MOOCs. Higher education is different from other sectors that can be digitized, like newspapers and music. The learner is not a mere consumer; both teacher and learner participate in an exchange of value, where the skill and understanding of the teacher is transformed into skill and understanding for the learner. This is a human event that can never be digitized or turned into an algorithm. 

Additionally, the characters in the article can't even see that they themselves have been acculturated into forms of interaction and knowledge which allow them to do their work -- values, acculturation, and socialization that absolutely cannot be replicated "online." Most likely, they went to traditional K-12 and higher education institutions. Content knowledge is good and an essential part of what higher education is all about, but I see no credibility in someone who thinks what happens inside a server farm is the same thing as happens in the K-12 and higher education systems. A handful of employees and a server farm an education does not make. If books couldn't supplant education, then why would the internet?

And Carey, the author of the article, loses all credibility with me when he upholds Wal-Mart then Facebook as models. The former thrives on low wage labor, international and domestic, and while Facebook provides a good service, its share price has gone from $38 at IPO to $19 today -- the definition of hype.

Carey's final line hits home for me, though, as he describes the future of higher ed: "Everyone else will scramble to survive as vestigial players." Sounds like the same logic that turned a generation of young academics into adjuncts.
No profanes - sacred
 
Calendar

March 2017
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031

January 2017
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031

December 2016
123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031


Older

Recent Visitors

March 30th
ontheway
google

March 29th
google

March 28th
morte
google

March 27th
ontheway
google

March 26th
google

March 25th
commntyblackman
google

March 24th
google

March 23rd
google

March 22nd
google
Spread Firefox